Top sources of links

Nivi suggested using the top sources of your links, in order to clean up your feedreader and throw out feeds you don’t find worthwile to bookmark links from anyway. It created some discussion on whether this was feasible/ethical/practical to build this as a service only requiring the (public) username (meaning you could probe any other user’s “attention stream”)

Reiterating my arguments:

From the point of view, that’s understandable

  • every user can retrieve his or her own data in the best Web2.0 tradition and recent entries are published as an rss feed (for notification and reuse purposes)…
  • but if it were allowed to query other user’s full data, the database would be leeched by the competition, and would loose its current lock-in (that lies in the accumulated data and the network-effect coming from the present userbase)

So the way to go was to use the api but that requires both username/pswd login for the request… So if you trust me that I don’t store your password*, and take the risk of sending a (non-encrypted) password (hopefully not the same as your really important pswds!) over http… then this form might be for you:



This extra feature is on my to-do list:

  • the export format is plain xml (<posts><post href = … ></posts>), which makes it more compact than RSS, Atom or RDF, but less readily reusable…
  • an optional conversion to RSS or Atom would be handy tool for people seeking to import their linklist in other apps

Oh, BTW, it took me more than 30 seconds, but hey, I’m not a Ruby on Rails programmer…

* I do cache the fetched linklists for 2 hours however – but again, I promise I don’t have any plans with them!


I made the export tab-separated, so you could copy-paste in MS Excel… Results aren’t spread over cells as they should be however… is there a way to do this without having to save and going via the import txt data wizard?

20 Responses to “Top sources of links”

  1. Nivi Says:

    This rocks. I will write on it.

    Send me your paypal, I owe you $50.

    Some ideas:

    1. Can you number the items on the list so I can see who is #1, #2, #382, etc.?

    2. What percentage of my bookmarks are from a source with only 1 bookmark? i.e. how much area is under the long tail?

    3. Use some kind of sparkline so I can see the time distribution of bookmarks for each source. i.e. have i found anything useful from this source lately?

  2. Nivi Says:

    Another idea: beside each source, put links to each of the bookmarks from that source.

  3. Nivi Says:

    I suppose it would be helpful if each of the sources was a hyperlink too… I think I have reached the “Land of What Must be Obvious to Pascal”

  4. Library clips Says:

    Rank sources of your links

    Top sources of links is a place to see the top sources according to all of your links.
    This way you can see the sources that matter the most to you, although as said in a comment to the Nivi post:
    “The problem is that D…

  5. Pascal Says:

    Nivi, I will look into it coming weekend!
    Thx for the 2-year subscription to Flickr!!

  6. Afvragingen Says:

    Bloggersbijeenkomst in Brussel

    Bloggers zijn doorgaans anoniemeriken. Ze leiden een tegenstrijdig leven. Ze pleuren dingen op het web die honderden (duizenden…) mensen onder ogen krijgen, maar zitten daarvoor wel uren achter een computerscherm in hun knusse huisje. Ze mogen nog zo…

  7. Nivi : Done: Attention-Mining Says:

    [...] to-be) famous Pascal Van Hecke has created the web service I seek. It rocks and I left him comments on how the service could be improved. You can find my t [...]

  8. Visualizing Roundup » Solution Watch Says:

    [...] tware. Mapping – Plots locations on the world map from geotags. Your top sources – Nivi had proposed a $50 bounty to who can m [...]

  9. Pascal Says:

    So much attention and it isn’t even finished yet…
    I didn’t manage to finish it during the weekend, but I’ll post an update with Nivi’s suggestions included in a new blog entry!

  10. mardoen Says:

    I’ve been thinking about these security issues as well — it sucks that you have to give away your full login just to get read-only access to your personal database. This is not a problem, this is a problem with any web service that you want to connect to: Flickr, blog software, etc.

    The problem is that there is enormous value in connecting to these services and getting/manipulating your data, and virtually all of the applications that currently are exciting today require you to give up yout login.

    Service providers should give users ways to connect client software to their databases. I’ve written a bit about this here: and propose a solution based on authentification tokens here:

    If you’re interested in using web services as a developer or user, and most of all if you’re a service provider yourself, please take some time to read at least the second article (it’s short) and tell me what you think. We really need to fix this. We’ll have major security problems with this in the future if we don’t.

  11. mardoen Says:

    Oh, and…
    Pascal: looks like a nice service, but I didn’t actually use it ;)
    It’s not that I don’t trust you, it’s just that I don’t give away passwords to my data. I’d try it if you let users give you the XML output of the posts/all API function instead, it’s simple to retrieve from within any browser. (Problem with that: it’s a lot of data, might be too much for a web form.)

  12. Woeba - Where do the links I add to come from? Says:

    [...] that you’ve bookmarked pages from, so you can see which sites you find most useful. Top sources of links Popularity: unranked


  13. joshua Says:

    Hi there. I’ve been thinking about the cross-website authentication problems you guys are talking about. I’ve spoke a little bit about it on the mailing list. I’ll have a proposal and implementation done in a few weeks.


  14. mardoen Says:

    man, this rocks. I love it that you are the first to do it, because you have the freedom to do it right, and the exposure and popularity to motivate others to follow suit.

  15. If incoming links meant money… Says:

    [...] s data in a way not yet seen before. That was a bit the case for the really simple “Top sources of links” posting, it is also the case for t [...]

  16. reflective cell-animal vision » Blog Archive » summary Says:

    [...] y more waiting to be added). My top bookmark sources (courtasy of Pascal van Hecke’s service): 14 13 13 9 n [...]

  17. Anywhere but in-between » & google/ig Says:

    [...] Given such a cloud, I want to drop it into google/ig as a module, like this for my tags only with different data.I’m sensitive to the idea that doesn’t want to leave alltheir href=””>datahanging out in the open – I’m not asking for databaseaccess.  If they’d generate the cloud like they do the tag rolls, I’dbe just as happy.  I’ll link back to them regardless. [...]

  18. links for 2007-08-22 « Rob Edwards: Collection of my daily bookmarks: roedward Says:

    [...] Top sources of links (tags: tools rss delicious Web2.0 XML) Posted by roedward Filed in Uncategorized [...]

  19. DEL.ICIO.US TOOLBOX: 180+ Tools and Resources Says:

    [...] Your top sources- See your top bookmark sources. [...]

  20. David D Says:

    I know this is REALLY old, but the tool isn’t working for me. Has there been a change in the Delicious API, or do you know of another tool that can show frequently bookmarked URLs/sources in a Delicious account?