Comments on: What’s wrong with blog commenting (and what can you do about it)?

By: Site about

Site about — Mon, 19 Mar 2007 11:35:49 +0000

bvstqi. http://www.wildorchidz.com/?pid=nude_cam_0319 SITE ABOUT

By: Dushyant

Dushyant — Tue, 30 May 2006 04:55:18 +0000

Some nice suggestions, thanks.

By: Pascal

Pascal — Fri, 31 Mar 2006 15:48:45 +0000

@squashed: what a great idea!
But… why haven’t I had your thought before ? ;-)

By: squashed

squashed — Fri, 31 Mar 2006 06:20:57 +0000

Commenting is so overated. We all should start using telepathic communication instead.

By: Clopin

Clopin — Thu, 09 Mar 2006 14:03:14 +0000

Check out what Assaf suggested, I think you might like it. Also check another comparable tool: http://www.cocomment.com

By: Diego

Diego — Thu, 16 Feb 2006 08:12:05 +0000

Hi Pascal!!

Sorry about the waiting!

Well, if there is something good I did with MyCo is to liberate the API doc very soon, this was used with a lot of people and added a lot of features. One of this features, is going to be available in a few days and is what you wanted, a WordPress plugin showing all your comments ammong the blogosphere :).

I really don’t understud what you say about releasing the server app … this would be a little messy, since there would be a lot of mini installations, when the greatest thing about this is it’s centralization, I think…

Greets! Diego

By: assaf

assaf — Wed, 15 Feb 2006 16:55:43 +0000

Pascal,

What do you think of http://co.mments.com?

By: Lorenzo Viscanti

Lorenzo Viscanti — Sat, 11 Feb 2006 13:17:30 +0000

Hi, at Clipperz we’re developing a cross platform comment service. Our system will be similar to cocomment (as it will allow commenters/bloggers to follow discussions originated by their comments) but powered by an identity20 interface (as sxore). Sxore has a centralized vision, where comments are stored by their server (and shown in blogs but from their server), while clipperz will leave comments on the blogging platform, reducing comment spam and enabling comments discussions. Take a look at our blog (http://www.clipperz.net)with our propositions!

By: Pascal

Pascal — Fri, 10 Feb 2006 00:37:03 +0000

Hi Diego,

I had a look at your blog and really, I don’t believe your intention is to harvest mail addresses in order to spam them :-)

You said it’s meant for you and your blogosphere, so for people who know and trust you. And that you built it in the first place for yourself (“scratch your own itch” – which is how really useful projects start).

I think a self-hosted CoComments-like solution is a very nice idea, but what I do not understand is that you haven’t release the source code of the receiving end. There are lots of solutions thinkable for the receiving end, you could put the results in a dedicated table and in your own application, but also in scuttle (= a self-hosted del.icio.us) or similar apps… The receiving end I had in mind (I hope to have time for one of the coming weeks), would be a WordPress plugin that collects the received comments in the WordPress comments table as comments to a page (so there will be a page on my WordPress blog that will display the comments I made elsewhere). Together with the para.site bookmarklet, this would enable people to automatically harvest the comments they make elsewhere on their own blog, a sort of commentblog…

Also your own setup, where the Mycomments server is the hub of your own blogosphere (and not only any more collecting your own comments), would be a very productive idea for other people to implement in their blogosphere (= a collection of blogs/bloggers on a certain topic that intercomment and interlink freqently). It would combine the good things of blogging and forums in a semi-centralised, semi decentralised system… Hmm, inspiration for coding and experimenting so it seems….

By: botanik

botanik — Wed, 08 Feb 2006 18:29:49 +0000

Hola Diego!

i guess you are subscribed to this conversation in pascals blog, this is something im liking a lot, conversations now dont belong to one or the other site so much as before, I dont have to go into you blog to ask cause i kind of trust you will receive my note.. i like that!

could anyone help me clarify if the difference between one model and the other is that the conversation page generated by one is centralized on a remote server and the second one is created on the local server where the blog is located?

thanks,
/bk